Last fall, the stupid father released the evaluation of the small capacity straw thermal insulation cup of about 300ml. (Click to review:
10 baby straws insulation cup evaluation: This 299 yuan performance is not as good as 99 yuan
)
Some time ago, I also recommended a Little Tiny straw insulation cup (320ml) with excellent evaluation.
This autumn and winter, let’s evaluate again, that is
Large -capacity insulation cup
After the baby is around 3 years old, after especially in kindergarten, he began to use more large -capacity thermal insulation cups.
In this evaluation, the stupid father chose 12 large -capacity children’s insulation cups (more than 550ml) with high sales on the market to conduct a detailed comparison evaluation, with a view to providing professional and objective purchase reference for the Baoma.
Routine statement
: The evaluation of the large -capacity children’s insulation cup is a neutral position. The stupid father does not accept advertisements and sponsorships trying to affect the authenticity and objectiveness of the evaluation results.
Table of contents
1. Evaluate samples
2. Evaluation indicator
3. The first round: use performance evaluation
4. Second round: safety testing
5. Comprehensive recommendation
Evaluation sample
Comprehensive e -commerce platform sales, brand awareness, fan voting, capacity and other factors, the stupid father chose the following 12 children’s insulation cups as evaluation objects.
▲ Sample map
Sample description:
1. There are three specifications of 12 insulation cups: 550ml, 600ml, and 630ml. The volume and weight are large, which is more suitable for children with 3 years and above. Among them, 9 models are 600ml.
2. Among the 12 insulation cups, 7 models are one cup of triple use (straw -type/direct drink/pour water), and 5 are a cup of dual -use type (straw type/pour water). The straw type, which contains a straw; drink straight, lifts up the neck and drink;
3. The price of 12 thermos cups is between 99 yuan and 389 yuan. The price of the pictorial and the magician exceeds 300 yuan, which is a higher -end price. The other 10 models belong to the low -end price.
Evaluation indicator
The first round: use performance evaluation
① Inspiration ② Sealing ③ Falling resistance ④ odor test ⑤ Baby experience ⑥ Mom use experience
Second round: safety testing
The first round of comprehensive scores are arranged in the top 5 thermal cups, and then laboratory testing of the material safety of its mouth, the inner orchestra, and the cup lid. The indicators include:
① Virginity organic matter ② Total migration volume ③ Migration can be migrated, heavy metal ④ potassium permanganate consumption, etc.
Finally, based on the results of the two rounds of evaluation, comprehensively recommend it.
The following officially enters the evaluation link.
Insulation
Evaluation method
: In order to examine the insulation performance of various thermal insulation cups under different environmental conditions, the stupid father designed 4 evaluation methods -the national standard method, daily law, winter method, and fall resistance test, the specific operation is as follows:
Evaluation results:
1. According to the national standard “GB/T 29606-2013 Stainless Steel Vacuum Cup”, the capacity of 550ml-630ml and a caliber between 34mm — 94mm (manual measurement) cups. about.
The picture below is 12 insulation cups
National standard law
Test Results:
As a result, the thermal insulation efficiency of the 12 insulation cups meets the national standard. After 6H, the water temperature is 71.8 ° C -77.2 ° C, which is much higher than the minimum limit required by the national standard.
in,
Good boy, tiger card, cup bear
The top three of the National standard Law,
Fuguang, babycare, Disney
Ranking at the bottom, the maximum temperature difference is 5.4 ℃.
2. In daily life, Baoma usually contains hot water around 50 ° C instead of hot water of 95 ° C, otherwise the baby cannot drink directly. This is also the suggestion of various brands.
Daily law
The results can be seen, in the daily method test,
Good children, cups, elephant seals
In the top three, the cooling water in 3H cups does not exceed 3 ° C, and the cooling water in 6H cups cools at about 4.5 ° C -5.1 ° C.
Disney, BabyCare, Thomas
Ranking at the bottom, compared with the top three, the insulation performance of 3H and 6H is about 1 ° C -2 ° C.
3. If you stay in the outdoor environment for a long time, can the hot water in the thermal insulation cup be hot?
12 insulation cups
Winter law
The test results are as follows:
It can be seen that in the winter method test,
Elephant seal, good boy, dine magician
In the top three, the cooling water in 3H cups does not exceed 4.5 ° C, and the cooling water in 6H cups does not exceed 9 ° C.
Disney, Fuguang, BabyCare
Line countdown.
4. Sometimes the baby has fallen and stabbed the insulation cup. Will the insulation effect worse?
After the 12 insulation cups ended the drop -resistant test (see the drop resistance test below), a daily insulation daily test was performed. The result is as follows:
After a drop -resistant test, most of the insulation of the 12 insulation cups is only slightly changed compared to before falling.
Fuguang, cup of bears
Slightly declined, but not exceeding 0.7 ° C, the drop is not very large, and the thermal insulation performance has not been significantly worse.
Comprehensive data, the insulation evaluation score of 12 children’s insulation cups is as follows (5 points in full score, the same is the same):
summary:
1. Generally speaking, good children, tiger cards, pictorials, cups, cups, and meal magicians, the comprehensive performance of thermal insulation performance is better.
2. The insulation performance of 12 insulation cups is not particularly different. Basically, it can meet the needs of “a bite of hot (temperature) water” within 6 hours in autumn and winter.
3. Compared with the evaluation results of the small capacity thermal insulation cup last year, the insulation performance of the large -capacity thermal insulation cup is relatively better. In addition, the more thermal water in the insulation cup, the better the insulation effect will be better.
Sealing
: In response to the sealing of the thermal insulation cup, the stupid father designed 3 simulation situations to test. The specific operation is as follows:
1. The simulation is shaken in the bag or baby’s hands. A cup of three -purpose/one cup of dual -use formula was tested. None of the 12 insulation cups did not leak.
(Example: Disney))
2. The simulation cup lid is not covered and shaken, 12 thermal insulation cups
Pour
There are no leakage.
(Example: Wu Tong)
Replace
Straw
Later, due to the design of the exhaust holes, the water in the 12 insulation cups will flow directly from the exhaust holes. A good child leaks a little better.
(Example: Cup Bear))
((
P.S.
Remind Moms, the straw type must be tightly covered, otherwise it may leak water when placing it obliquely. One cup of three -purpose direct drinking type is even more capable of covering a cup lid! )
3. Simulation in the static state or shaking, open the thermal insulation cup,
Good boy
The occurrence of water spray indicates that its exhaust resistance is not good enough. The other 11 insulation cups did not spray or overflow.
The reason is that the design of a good child’s exhaust holes is relatively small. Although it helps to prevent leakage, it affects the exhaust effect and may cause water spray and burn the baby.
To remind you more, some Baoma will load boiling water (such as before going to bed) in the thermal insulation cup, and then wait for the water temperature to fall down before drinking it for the baby, but this approach is not desirable! When the inside of the thermal insulation cup is more than 60 degrees of scalding water, be careful when the lid is opened in a straw, otherwise it will spray the burns!
After evaluation, the sealing score of the 12 children’s thermos cups is as follows:
Downside
: Put a hot water at 50 ° C in the thermal insulation cup, cover the cup lid, and make the insulation cup freely fall at two heights of 50cm/100cm. Whether the parts are intact.
1,
Steel magician, Wu Tong, Ke Youbi
, Blade the cup lid after the straw.
2,
Fuguang, Thomas, Cocoi
, Plug a side wall of the thermal insulation cup.
3,
Lexiele buckle, babycare, Thomas
, Disposal, sprinkle water, and cup lids in half.
4. The other five thermal heating cups have a good performance.
After evaluation, the score of the 12 children’s insulation cups is as follows:
Bad odor test
: Refer to the national standard “GB/T 29606-2013 Stainless Steel Vacuum Cup”, clean the thermos cup with warm water, fill the hot water above 90 ° C, and put the cup lid for 30 minutes.
Among the 12 insulation cups, Disney can still smell a little metal after cleaning, and the other 11 models are basically tasteless.
Baby use experience
: Simulate the baby to drink water, open/close the cup lid, go out and carry, and experience whether the baby’s daily use is comfortable and convenient.
1. Drink water experience
: Among the 12 insulation cups, only the rich light uses a cross -mouth suction. When absorbing water, it needs to be bite. To a certain extent, it can control the flow of water and prevent it.
The others are straight -through (round -hole) suction, without having to bite water absorption, there is no problem in using children at the age of 3 and above. in,
Lexiele, Wu Tong
It is slightly laborious when absorbing water, and the water flow is not smooth enough.
In addition, the temperature plug was installed on the straw cup of Fuguang, BabyCare, and Disney. The water temperature exceeded 50 ° C. Purple will become red, and the design is more secure and intimate.
: Among the 12 insulation cups, Wu Tong and Ke You should master the angle of pouring water when pouring water.
Cup bears, tiger cards, music buckles, pictima, good children, Thomas, the fluency of pouring water performed better.
Direct drinking
: Seven cups of three -with direct drinking cups. The diameter of the direct drinking tube is relatively large, the water flow is smooth, and the experience of drinking water is better.
2. Open/closing cup lid experience
Among the 12 insulation cups, the buttons of a good child’s direct drinking cup lid are not elastic enough, and sometimes it is necessary to manually open it.
There are no major problems to operate the other 11 cups of thermal heating cup, and the performance of the opening/level is relatively good.
3. Go out and carry experience
The 12 insulation cups are equipped with straps for easy carrying. Among them, there are only straps with good children, and 10 other models have both straps and cups. The cup sleeve can play a role in protecting the wall of the cup and preventing scraping from being broken.
BabyCare, Youbi, Wu Tong, a pocket on the cup set, can be placed in small objects.
In addition, the stupid father also tested the intensity of the strap. The straps of the 12 insulation cups have been dragged for 50 consecutive times. There is no problem with the strength of the strap. There is no need to worry about breaks and falling off in normal use.
(Example: Good boy)
After the evaluation, the baby of the 12 children’s thermos cups use the experience score as follows:
Mom use experience
: Simulation treasure mother installation/removing thermal insulation cups, cleaning thermos cups and other activities, experience the difficulty of using Baoma’s daily operation.
The
1. Install/disassemble
, Demolition is relatively simple, rotate the cup lid, and then disassemble the suction, straw, rubber ring one by one. Install the same reason.
(Example: Members)
7 types of three -purpose insulation cups, one cup, one,
The installation/disassembly only needs to rotate the cup lid, which is also very easy.
The difficulty of installing/disassembling is different.
Cup bears, tiger cards, meal magicians, good children, Thomas, Keyi, Wu Tong
The surface of the pour water type is not round or small, or the area is small, which causes it to be strenuous and not smooth when the twisting cover.
Especially Thomas, the surface of the bolt cover is uneven and the contact area is small.
2. Daily cleaning
The daily cleaning of the insulation cup needs special attention in the following places, otherwise it may be hidden.
In the straw -type cup lid, there is a narrow gap, and the liquid may be left in the interior. It is necessary to use a small tool to clean it.
In the straw -type and direct drinking buckle button, there is a gap, and the mouth is closer when drinking water. Pay attention to the liquid residue.
Inside the water -type midporation, the structure is more complicated, with different depths and unevenness. It should be regularly cleaned.
12 in thermal insulation cups
, Wu Tong, Keyi, Disney, Restaurant, BabyCare
The cleaning experience is relatively better.
After evaluation, the mother’s use of the 12 children’s insulation cups scores as follows:
The first round of performance evaluation summary
After the above performance testing, the stupid father divided the weights of each indicator according to the important degree, and the weighted average calculation was performed. The total score and ranking of the first round of the 12 large -capacity children’s insulation cups are as follows:
Tiger cards, pictorials, cups, cups, meal magicians, and good children, ranked among the top 5 of the first round of performance evaluation.
Based on the principles of selection of Youzhong, the stupid father sent the top 5 insulation cups to a third -party professional testing agency to conduct laboratory testing for material safety.
Laboratory safety testing
Sucking pipe, inner orchy, inverted cup lid
Because they have the highest contact with the baby’s mouth and the liquid in the cup. Specific test indicators include:
Sucking
: ① Total migration: detect whether there are non -volatile substance migration analysis and content; ② volatile organic matter: detect whether there are volatile organic matter migration and content.
Endless
: ① Specific migration of heavy metal arsenic cadmium lead chromium nickel: detect whether there are arsenic cadmium lead chromium nickel migration analysis and content.
Inverted cup lid
: ① Total migration; ② Consumption of potassium permanganate: detect whether there are soluble organic matter migration and content.
The following are the safety test results of 5 children’s insulation cups:
1. Suiss the mouth and straw
① The total migration volume of the tiger and elephant -printed straw straws is detected. The detection values are 24mg/kg and 26mg/kg, respectively, and less than 60mg/kg of the national standard limit, all meet the national standard.
② The suction and straws of the 5 insulation cups all detected volatile organic matter. There is no limit to the indicator in the national standard of thermal insulation cup. This time, it is based on “GB4806.2-2015 National Standard Packet”, which is relatively stricter to detect the sample.
Among them, the volatile organic objects of the good children, the magician, and the elephant seal were detected by the “pacifier national standard”, and the situation was ideal.
The detection value of the volatile organic matter of the tiger and cup is slightly exceeded that the “pacifier national standard” limit is exceeded. Considering that the large -capacity thermal insulation cup is mainly suitable for babies around 3 years old and above, and it is one of the ways of drinking water. The stupid father thinks that the impact is not too great, but he will make a lot of points on it.
2, inner lined
① The inner child of a good child detects heavy metal nickel migration, the detection value is 0.014mg/kg, and the national standard limit is 0.5mg/kg, which meets the national standard.
② The other four heavy metal migration test results of the other four insulation cups are: not detected.
3. Infalling water cup lid
The first round: use performance evaluation
Second round: safety testing
Evaluation method
Evaluation method
Evaluation method
Evaluation method
Evaluation method
Evaluation results:
Evaluation results:
Evaluation results:
Evaluation results:
Evaluation results:
The picture below is 12 insulation cups
Test Results:
12 insulation cups
12 insulation cups
summary:
Pour
Pour
(Example: Wu Tong)
Straw
Straw
(Example: Cup Bear))
Direct drinking
① The total migration volume of the cup lid of a good child is 24mg/kg, and the cup lid of the elephant is 2mg/kg.
② The total migration of the other three insulation cup lids and the detection results of potassium permanganate consumption are: not detected.
(P.S. Inspection Report, please enter the keyword “Brand Name+Inspection Report” in the background of the “Baby Review” WeChat public account background, such as “Cup Bear Test Report” and “Tiger Test Report”))
The results of the comprehensive test results, the second round of safety scores of the five large -capacity children’s insulation cups are as follows:
Comprehensive recommendation
According to the results of the two rounds of evaluation, the stupid father made a weighted average of the two -wheeled evaluation score. The final score and ranking of the five large -capacity children’s insulation cups are as follows:
Because the final score of the five insulation cups was closer, the stupid father listed them as a recommended product.
The price of the five heat insulation cups is between 198 yuan and 389 yuan. You can choose the advantages and disadvantages of each product, cost -effectiveness, and baby’s usage habits.
1. FFG-603WF
Reference price: 338 yuan/600ml
Evaluation
: Ranking the top five in thermal insulation performance; better sealing (note that the straw type needs to be covered with a cup lid), there is no problem with falling resistance under normal use; ; Mom installation/disassembly and cleaning are more convenient; laboratory safety testing performed better.
2. Elephant India SC-ZT60-BA
Reference price: 389 yuan/600ml
: The third comprehensive performance of insulation; better sealing (note that the straw type needs to be covered with a cup lid); better drop resistance; a cup of dual -use type (straw type, water inverted); uns designated cup cover, baby goes out to experience experience Generally; mothers are more convenient to install/disassemble and clean; various safety testing in the laboratory meets the national standard.
3. Cup bear RT104-630
Reference price: 198 yuan/630ml
: The fourth ranking of thermal insulation performance; better sealing (note that the straw type needs to be covered with a cup lid); better drop resistance; a cup triple use; the baby’s experience is good; the difficulty of the mother’s daily use is slightly inferior; the laboratory room; the laboratory room; the laboratory room; the laboratory room; the laboratory room; the laboratory room; The content of volatile organic objects for detecting the straws is slightly higher; the overall cost is relatively high.
4. Tiger MBJ-C06C
Reference price: 269 yuan/600ml
: Ranking second in thermal insulation performance; good drop resistance and sealing (note that the straw type needs to be covered with a cup lid); a cup of dual -use type (straw type, water pour type); The difficulty of disassembling/cleaning is slightly inferior; laboratory detection of volatile organic matter content in the laboratory is slightly higher.
5. Good boy H80224
Reference price: 199 yuan/600ml
: The comprehensive performance of insulation is the best; sealing and exhaust properties are general, and the straw type may spray water/overflow; better drop resistance; one cup and three -purpose formula; unless designed cup cover, baby opening and going out experience; mothers’ experience experience experience Slightly inferior; various safety testing in the laboratory meets the national standard, and the overall cost is relatively high.
Special statement:
The detection samples are purchased randomly and independently, and the detection data of different batches of products may fluctuate. The test results are only responsible for the delivery of batch products, but the stupid father believes that the quality of responsible enterprise products should be as stable as possible.
The above is the entire analysis of the evaluation of the large -capacity children’s insulation cup.
Well, this issue is over here. If you think the article is useful, please forward more support!
If you want to inquire more related articles, or if you have any questions, you want to consult. Welcome to pay attention to the “Baby Evaluation” WeChat public account (ID: baObaoPingce) and leave a message in the background. The stupid father will answer it alone.
Recap history
1, 32 national bank version milk powder comprehensive evaluation
2, 38 domestic milk powder comprehensive evaluation
3. Five version of the Milk Powder of the Beauty Milk Powder Complete Evaluation
4. Mesujiaer 23 milk powder comprehensive evaluation
5. Mead Johnson 33 milk powder comprehensive evaluation
6. A2 milk powder comprehensive evaluation
7, 66 bottle & pacifiers evaluation
8. Baby sunscreen evaluation
9. Baby mosquito repellent product big evaluation
10, 22 baby rice noodles evaluation
11, 13 babies vitamin D evaluation
12, 20 primary pants evaluation
………
Please check in the historical article of the “Baby Evaluation” headline; or pay attention to the “Baby Evaluation” WeChat public account (ID: baObaopingce), and enter the corresponding keyword query in the background.
For “Baby Evaluation”, please click “Learn more” below. Welcome to reward the stupid father.
Welcome to pay attention to “Baby Evaluation”. 7 years of commodity comparison testing experience, do not speculate, and use scientific and rational stupid methods to provide reliable consumer suggestions.
Evaluation
Evaluation
Evaluation
Evaluation